Unsung Heroes: The Most Surprising Special Teams Performances of the 2025 NFL Season
The roar of the crowd, the dazzling displays of athleticism, and the strategic battles on the gridiron – these are the elements that define the NFL. Yet, beneath the surface of every game lies a realm of often-overlooked contributions: special teams. In the 2025 season, several unsung heroes emerged, delivering surprising performances that shifted momentum and defied expectations. While quarterbacks and wide receivers often steal the headlines, these special teams dynamos proved that football is truly a three-phase game.
The Rise of Jamal Agnew: Return Specialist Extraordinaire
Jamal Agnew of the Kansas City Chiefs etched his name in special teams history this season. While the Chiefs’ offense, led by Patrick Mahomes, remained a force, Agnew provided a spark that ignited the team in crucial moments. Agnew not only consistently provided excellent field position, but he also turned the tide of multiple games with electrifying punt and kick returns.
In Week 7 against the Las Vegas Raiders, with the Chiefs trailing by a touchdown, Agnew fielded a punt at his own 10-yard line. What followed was a breathtaking display of speed and agility as he weaved through the Raiders’ coverage unit, exploding for a 90-yard touchdown. This play not only tied the game but also injected a surge of energy into the Chiefs, who went on to secure a decisive victory. Agnew’s performance earned him Special Teams Player of the Week honors and solidified his status as a game-changer.
The Accuracy of Anders Carlson: A Kicking Revelation
The Green Bay Packers’ Anders Carlson entered the 2025 season with question marks surrounding his consistency. However, Carlson silenced his doubters with a remarkable display of accuracy and clutch performance. He became a reliable weapon for the Packers, consistently splitting the uprights and delivering crucial points in tight contests.
Carlson’s most memorable moment came in Week 12 against the Minnesota Vikings. With the game tied and time winding down, the Packers faced a daunting 57-yard field goal attempt. The crowd held its breath as Carlson stepped up and launched the ball through the uprights, securing a dramatic victory for Green Bay. Carlson’s unwavering composure and booming leg proved to be invaluable assets for the Packers throughout the season.
The Coverage Prowess of Jalen Reeves-Maybin: A Tackling Machine
Jalen Reeves-Maybin of the Detroit Lions exemplified the grit and determination that define special teams excellence. While his name may not be widely recognized, Reeves-Maybin’s impact on the Lions’ special teams unit was undeniable. He consistently made crucial tackles, disrupted opposing returners, and provided relentless energy on every play.
Reeves-Maybin’s standout performance came in the NFC Championship game against the Philadelphia Eagles. With the Lions clinging to a narrow lead, Reeves-Maybin made two critical tackles on kickoff coverage, pinning the Eagles deep in their own territory. These stops limited the Eagles’ scoring opportunities and helped the Lions secure a hard-fought victory, earning them a trip to the Super Bowl. Reeves-Maybin’s selflessness and unwavering commitment to special teams made him an indispensable part of the Lions’ success.
The Falcons Find a Gem in Avery Johnson
The Atlanta Falcons’ recent roster moves, including signing special teams ace Avery Johnson, highlight the importance of this often-overlooked aspect of the game. Johnson’s journey from an undrafted rookie to a key special teams player embodies determination and the pursuit of excellence. His high participation rates and tactical understanding make him a crucial asset for the Falcons, who recognize the significant impact special teams can have on game outcomes.
The Chiefs’ Secret Weapon: James Winchester
Continuity and reliability are highly valued in the NFL, especially on special teams. James Winchester, the long snapper for the Kansas City Chiefs, exemplifies these qualities. Having played for the Chiefs for ten seasons, Winchester’s consistent performance has been a key factor in Harrison Butker’s success as one of the league’s best kickers. Winchester’s ability to stay healthy and perform his role flawlessly makes him an unsung hero for the Chiefs.
Rookie Impact: Ricky White III
Ricky White III from UNLV, drafted as a wide receiver, showcased exceptional special teams ability, earning a PFF special teams grade of 91.9 in 2024, the highest for a college player in six seasons. His knack for blocking punts makes him a valuable asset and a player to watch.
The Overlooked Value of Special Teams
These unsung heroes of the 2025 NFL season demonstrate the profound impact that special teams can have on the outcome of games. Their surprising performances, whether through electrifying returns, clutch kicks, or relentless coverage, underscore the importance of recognizing and appreciating the contributions of these often-overlooked players. As the game continues to evolve, special teams will undoubtedly remain a critical component of success, and the unsung heroes who excel in this phase of the game will continue to surprise and inspire fans.