UDFA Gems: Sleepers and Surprise Impact Players to Watch After the 2025 NFL Draft

The NFL Draft is a whirlwind of excitement, where dreams are realized and potential superstars are chosen. However, the draft is not the end of the road for all aspiring players. In fact, some of the most impactful and memorable careers have been forged by those who went undrafted. Just ask Kurt Warner, who went from stocking shelves to winning Super Bowl MVP, or Antonio Gates, the basketball player who became one of the greatest tight ends in NFL history. As the dust settles from the 2025 NFL Draft, it’s time to turn our attention to the undrafted free agents (UDFAs) who are eager to prove their worth. These players, often overlooked due to perceived flaws in size, speed, or experience, represent incredible value and potential for teams willing to give them a chance.

The Allure of the Underdog: Why UDFAs Matter

Every year, hundreds of college players enter the NFL Draft, but only a select few are chosen. The rest must navigate the challenging path of undrafted free agency. Despite the odds, UDFAs have consistently defied expectations and carved out significant roles for themselves. Adam Vinatieri, arguably the greatest kicker of all time, was an undrafted free agent. James Harrison, a former Defensive Player of the Year, also entered the league as a UDFA. These stories highlight the importance of scouting beyond the headlines and recognizing the hidden talent that exists in every draft class.

The success of UDFAs can be attributed to several factors. First, these players often possess a relentless work ethic and a burning desire to prove their doubters wrong. They are willing to go the extra mile, putting in the extra hours in the film room and on the practice field. Second, UDFAs often bring a unique skill set or perspective to the game. They may have overcome adversity or taken a non-traditional path to the NFL, which can make them more adaptable and resilient. Finally, UDFAs benefit from the opportunity to learn and develop within a professional environment. They are surrounded by experienced coaches and players who can help them refine their skills and reach their full potential.

Identifying the Gems: Key Traits to Watch

So, how do we identify the UDFAs who have the best chance to make an impact? While there is no foolproof formula, there are several key traits to watch for:

Versatility: Players who can play multiple positions or contribute on special teams are highly valuable.
Special Teams Prowess: Excelling on special teams is often the quickest way for a UDFA to earn a roster spot and playing time.
Football IQ: The ability to quickly learn and understand complex schemes is crucial for success at the NFL level.
Coachability: Players who are receptive to coaching and willing to adapt their game are more likely to improve and contribute.
Intangibles: Qualities like leadership, character, and work ethic can make a significant difference in a player’s development and performance.

Standout UDFAs from the 2025 NFL Draft

The 2025 NFL Draft class is brimming with intriguing UDFA prospects. Here are a few names to keep an eye on:

Jeremiah Byers, T, Arizona Cardinals: The Cardinals’ UDFA class has a clear theme: the offensive line. Byers stands out for his consistency across six seasons of college action. He surrendered only seven sacks in that span, four coming in his 2021 campaign, and posted 70.0-plus PFF pass-blocking grades in his final two seasons at Florida State.
Nick Nash, WR, Atlanta Falcons: The Falcons put together a stacked UDFA class, featuring five players on PFF’s big board. Nash could boost the Falcons’ receiving corps.
Max Brosmer, QB, Minnesota Vikings: Brosmer had two prolific seasons at FCS New Hampshire before transferring to Minnesota for 2024 and starting 12 games for the Golden Gophers. He completed 66.8 percent of his passes for 2,617 yards, with 17 touchdowns and five interceptions, adding five rushing scores despite having minus-34 rushing yards.
Donovan Edwards, RB, New York Jets: Edwards got plenty of playing time on passing downs, recording 86 receptions during his Michigan career, and he then ran a 4.44 40 at the 2025 Combine (at 5-foot-11, 205 pounds).
Raheim Sanders, RB, Los Angeles Chargers: Sanders looked like a legit NFL prospect after he ran for 578 yards in 2021 as a true freshman at Arkansas and then exploded for a 222-1,443-10 rushing line in 2022 (6.5 YPC, plus 28-271-2 receiving).

Teams with a History of UDFA Success

Some NFL teams have a knack for identifying and developing UDFA talent. The Dallas Cowboys, for example, have a long and storied history of UDFA success, from Cliff Harris to Tony Romo to Markquese Bell. The Pittsburgh Steelers, New England Patriots, and Green Bay Packers are also known for their ability to find diamonds in the rough. These teams often prioritize scouting and player development, creating an environment where UDFAs can thrive.

The UDFA Mindset: Overcoming Obstacles

Making it as an undrafted free agent requires a unique mindset. These players must be resilient, determined, and willing to embrace the grind. They face an uphill battle, but they also have an opportunity to prove their worth and defy expectations. Tommy Devito, an undrafted free agent who signed with the New York Giants, has reignited NFL fans’ skepticism regarding the league’s ability to identify and draft the most talented eligible players.

The Impact of UDFAs on Team Success

The impact of UDFAs extends beyond individual success stories. These players can provide valuable depth, contribute on special teams, and even emerge as starters. They can also bring a unique perspective and a sense of urgency to a team. In many cases, UDFAs are the unsung heroes who help teams overcome adversity and achieve their goals.

Looking Ahead: The Future of UDFAs in the NFL

As the NFL continues to evolve, the role of UDFAs is likely to become even more important. With increasing emphasis on roster depth and special teams play, teams will need to rely on UDFAs to fill critical roles. The ability to identify and develop these players will be a key differentiator for successful organizations.

The 2025 NFL Draft may be over, but the journey for these UDFA players is just beginning. They have the talent, the drive, and the opportunity to make their mark on the league. Keep an eye on these underdogs as they strive to become the next UDFA gems.