Rookie Report Card: Grading the Impact of the 2024 NFL Draft Class on the 2025 Season
The 2024 NFL Draft class has officially completed its rookie season, leaving a significant mark on the league and setting the stage for the 2025 season. With several first-year players exceeding expectations and others facing growing pains, it’s time to assess the overall impact of this class and hand out some grades. Did the rookies live up to the hype, or will their teams be looking for more in the coming year? Let’s dive into the standout performers, surprising disappointments, and potential game-changers from the 2024 NFL Draft.
Quarterback Class: A New Era Under Center
The quarterback class of 2024 was highly anticipated, and several rookies stepped into starting roles immediately. Jayden Daniels of the Washington Commanders quickly became a frontrunner for Offensive Rookie of the Year. Daniels completed nearly 70% of his passes for 2,819 yards and 15 touchdowns, adding 590 rushing yards and six scores on the ground. According to Sports Info Solutions, Daniels led all rookies with 113 Total Points. His dual-threat ability transformed the Commanders’ offense, leading them to an NFC title game appearance.
Bo Nix of the Denver Broncos also impressed, leading his team to an 8-5 record through Week 13 and throwing 17 touchdowns. Nix’s experience in college allowed him to transition smoothly to the NFL, providing stability and leadership to the Broncos’ offense.
However, not all rookie quarterbacks found immediate success. Caleb Williams of the Chicago Bears had a mixed first season. Despite a strong supporting cast, Williams struggled with decision-making and often held the ball too long, leading to sacks. While he showed flashes of potential, his low football IQ was alarming, and some analysts believe the Bears made the wrong choice by selecting him over Daniels.
Drake Maye of the New England Patriots also faced challenges. While his toughness and willingness to protect his quarterback earned praise, the Patriots’ offensive struggles limited his impact. Maye’s development will be crucial for the Patriots’ future, but he needs a stronger supporting cast to thrive.
Wide Receiver Wonders: Immediate Impact on the Perimeter
The 2024 draft class boasted several talented wide receivers who made an immediate impact on their respective teams. Malik Nabers of the New York Giants proved to be a centerpiece of their offense, averaging 2.17 yards per route run and earning an 87.1 PFF receiving grade. Nabers hauled in 109 receptions for 1,204 yards, becoming a reliable target for the Giants’ quarterbacks.
Marvin Harrison Jr. of the Arizona Cardinals was a key part of their offense, particularly in the red zone. Harrison scored seven touchdowns in his first 12 games, showcasing his ability to make contested catches and contribute in crucial situations. Despite not reaching 1,000 receiving yards, Harrison’s strong first year demonstrated his potential to be a top receiver in the league.
Brian Thomas Jr. of the Jacksonville Jaguars emerged as a top deep threat, averaging 14.7 yards per reception. Thomas accumulated 1,282 receiving yards and became a favorite target for Trevor Lawrence.
Ladd McConkey of the Los Angeles Chargers quickly became Justin Herbert’s preferred target, posting a 2.48 Yards Per Route Run number. McConkey’s ability to create separation and make plays downfield added a new dimension to the Chargers’ passing game.
Running Back Revival: Fresh Legs in the Backfield
The running back class of 2024 saw several rookies emerge as valuable contributors to their teams. Bucky Irving of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers had an outstanding debut season, totaling 1,514 yards from scrimmage. Irving’s ability to excel as both a runner and receiver made him a versatile weapon for the Buccaneers’ offense. He averaged 4.03 yards after contact per carry and forced 57 missed tackles, showcasing his elusiveness and power. According to PFF, Irving was the highest-graded rookie of 2024.
Ray Davis of the Buffalo Bills provided valuable depth and production as a backup running back. Davis ran for 442 yards, with 323 of those yards coming after contact. His physical running style and ability to gain tough yards made him a reliable option for the Bills.
Tight End Talent: A New Generation of Pass-Catchers
Brock Bowers of the Las Vegas Raiders rewrote the record books for rookie tight ends. Bowers led all rookie pass catchers in total points. His impact was immediate and significant, providing a reliable target for the Raiders’ quarterbacks.
Defensive Dynamos: Impactful Rookies on Defense
The 2024 NFL Draft also produced several impactful defensive rookies who made their presence felt from day one. Jared Verse of the Los Angeles Rams led all rookies in pressures and ranked second among all players. Verse’s ability to disrupt opposing quarterbacks and generate sacks transformed the Rams’ defensive line.
Cooper DeJean of the Philadelphia Eagles showcased his versatility and playmaking ability in the secondary. DeJean’s coverage skills and ball-hawking instincts made him a valuable asset for the Eagles’ defense.
Offensive Line Anchors: Building Blocks for the Future
Joe Alt of the Los Angeles Chargers proved to be a solid and reliable presence on the offensive line. Alt’s steady pass protection and run-blocking skills provided stability for the Chargers’ offense.
Taliese Fuaga of the New Orleans Saints also impressed, demonstrating his ability to protect the quarterback and create running lanes. Fuaga’s performance suggests he will be a key part of the Saints’ offensive line for years to come.
Grading the Classes: Which Teams Nailed the Draft?
Several teams stood out for their successful 2024 draft classes. The Washington Commanders earned high praise for selecting Jayden Daniels and building a strong foundation for the future. The Los Angeles Rams also received excellent grades for adding Jared Verse and Braden Fiske to their defensive line. The New York Giants were commended for drafting Malik Nabers and finding valuable contributors in later rounds.
Other teams, however, faced criticism for their draft selections. The Minnesota Vikings were questioned for their limited number of picks and failure to address key defensive needs. The Cleveland Browns received low grades for a lack of significant contributions from their rookie class.
Looking Ahead to 2025: Building on Rookie Success
As the 2025 season approaches, teams will be looking to build on the success of their rookie classes and address remaining roster needs. Several teams have clear priorities for the 2025 NFL Draft. The Tennessee Titans need a franchise quarterback and edge rusher. The Cleveland Browns also need a quarterback. The Green Bay Packers need to improve their pass rush and add depth at cornerback. The Washington Commanders need to bolster their defense.
The 2024 NFL Draft class has set the stage for an exciting 2025 season. With several rookies poised to take on larger roles and continue their development, the future of the league looks bright.