Raiders Eyeing a Draft Day Leap? Potential QB Targets and Trade Scenarios

Raiders Eyeing a Draft Day Leap? Potential QB Targets and Trade Scenarios

The Las Vegas Raiders’ quarterback situation has been a revolving door since Derek Carr’s departure, and the 2025 NFL Draft could be the key to finding a long-term solution. With the draft just around the corner, rumors are swirling that the Raiders are considering a significant move to secure their quarterback of the future. After finishing the 2024 season with a 8-9 record, the Raiders hold the No. 13 overall pick. But, will they stay put, or will General Manager Tom Telesco make a bold move up the draft board?

Potential QB Targets: The Cream of the Crop

This year’s draft class boasts several quarterbacks with franchise potential, making it an attractive proposition for a team like the Raiders.

  • Caleb Williams, USC: Widely regarded as the top prospect, Williams possesses exceptional arm talent, mobility, and playmaking ability. While he’s expected to go No. 1 overall to the Chicago Bears, his name is still worth mentioning due to his high ceiling.
  • Drake Maye, North Carolina: Maye offers a blend of size, arm strength, and athleticism. Some analysts see him as a potential Josh Allen-type player, with the caveat that he needs refinement in his decision-making.
  • Jayden Daniels, LSU: The 2024 Heisman Trophy winner, Daniels is a dynamic dual-threat quarterback with electrifying running ability and improved passing accuracy. His slender frame raises some durability concerns, but his upside is undeniable.
  • J.J. McCarthy, Michigan: McCarthy led Michigan to a national championship with his efficient play and leadership. While he may not have the same wow factor as the others, his accuracy, decision-making, and winning pedigree make him an intriguing prospect.
  • Michael Penix Jr., Washington: Penix Jr. is coming off a stellar season where he led the Huskies to the National Championship game. His arm talent is undeniable, but his injury history is a concern.

Trade Scenarios: What Would It Take?

Moving up in the draft is never cheap, and the Raiders would likely need to part with a significant package of picks to land one of the top quarterbacks. Potential trade partners include the Washington Commanders (No. 2), New England Patriots (No. 3), and Arizona Cardinals (No. 4).

Here are a few possible trade scenarios:

  • Scenario 1: Trade with the Commanders for No. 2 Pick

    • Raiders Receive: No. 2 overall pick
    • Commanders Receive: No. 13 overall pick, 2025 first-round pick, 2026 second-round pick, and a player (e.g., DE Tyree Wilson).
    • Analysis: This would be a steep price, but it would guarantee the Raiders the opportunity to draft either Drake Maye or Jayden Daniels. The Commanders, in turn, would acquire additional draft capital to rebuild their roster.

  • Scenario 2: Trade with the Patriots for No. 3 Pick

    • Raiders Receive: No. 3 overall pick
    • Patriots Receive: No. 13 overall pick, 2025 first-round pick, and a 2026 third-round pick.
    • Analysis: This trade would be slightly less expensive than the Commanders’ deal, but the Raiders would still need to surrender valuable future assets. The Patriots, who have multiple needs, could use the extra picks to address other positions.

  • Scenario 3: Trade with the Cardinals for No. 4 Pick

    • Raiders Receive: No. 4 overall pick
    • Cardinals Receive: No. 13 overall pick, 2025 second-round pick, and a player (e.g., WR Hunter Renfrow).
    • Analysis: This would be the most affordable option, but it would also carry the risk of missing out on their preferred quarterback. The Cardinals, who already have Kyler Murray, might be willing to trade down to acquire more assets.

Staying Put: Drafting at No. 13

Of course, the Raiders could also choose to stay put at No. 13 and draft the best player available. In this scenario, they might target a player like J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr. if they are still on the board. They could also address other needs, such as offensive line or cornerback, with a top prospect like Olu Fashanu (OT, Penn State) or Quinyon Mitchell (CB, Toledo).

The Impact of Aidan O’Connell

Aidan O’Connell’s performance in the 2024 season adds another layer to the Raiders’ draft strategy. While he showed flashes of potential, he also struggled with consistency and turnovers. The Raiders must decide whether they believe O’Connell can be their long-term starter or if they need to find a more dynamic playmaker.

Expert Opinions and Mock Drafts

The NFL media is abuzz with speculation about the Raiders’ draft plans.

  • Mel Kiper Jr. (ESPN): Kiper has mocked the Raiders trading up to No. 3 to select Drake Maye, citing their desperate need for a franchise quarterback.
  • Todd McShay (ESPN): McShay believes the Raiders will stay put at No. 13 and draft Michael Penix Jr., viewing him as a high-upside prospect with the potential to be a star.
  • Daniel Jeremiah (NFL Network): Jeremiah predicts the Raiders will trade up to No. 4 to select Jayden Daniels, impressed by his dual-threat ability and leadership qualities.

The Telesco Factor

This will be Tom Telesco’s first draft as the Raiders’ general manager, and his approach remains a mystery. During his tenure with the Chargers, Telesco was known for being relatively conservative in the draft, preferring to build through player development rather than making splashy trades. However, the Raiders’ current quarterback situation may force him to be more aggressive.

Conclusion: A Franchise-Altering Decision

The Raiders’ decision in the 2025 NFL Draft will have a significant impact on the future of the franchise. Whether they trade up for a top quarterback, stay put and draft the best player available, or address other needs, the Raiders must make the right choice to compete in the tough AFC West. The pressure is on Tom Telesco to deliver a winning team to Las Vegas.