Kyle Pitts on the Move? Analyzing the Fantasy Football Impact of a Potential Trade
The Atlanta Falcons’ offense sputtered in 2024, leaving fantasy football managers frustrated and searching for answers. One of the biggest disappointments was tight end Kyle Pitts, who failed to live up to the immense hype that surrounded him coming out of the University of Florida. Now, as the 2025 season approaches, trade rumors are swirling around Pitts, leaving fantasy owners wondering: what would a change of scenery mean for his fantasy value?
Pitts’ Underwhelming Performance in Atlanta
Expectations were sky-high when the Falcons selected Pitts with the fourth overall pick in the 2021 NFL Draft. He was touted as a generational talent, a tight end with the size and athleticism of a wide receiver. His rookie season offered a glimpse of that potential, as he racked up 68 receptions for 1,026 yards. However, since then, Pitts’ production has declined.
In 2024, Pitts recorded career lows in receptions (47) and receiving yards (602) despite playing in all 17 games. He did manage to find the end zone four times, but his overall performance left much to be desired. His struggles can be attributed to a number of factors, including inconsistent quarterback play, questionable offensive play-calling, and lingering effects from a previous knee injury. According to Pro Football Focus, Pitts’ offensive grade was only the 44th-best among tight ends in the league.
Trade Rumors and Potential Destinations
With Pitts entering the final year of his rookie contract, the Falcons may be considering trading him to acquire draft capital or address other needs on their roster. Several teams have been mentioned as potential landing spots for the talented but underperforming tight end.
New York Jets: ESPN’s Bill Barnwell proposed a trade that would send Pitts to the Jets in exchange for the No. 15 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft and a 2026 third-round pick. The Jets are in desperate need of offensive weapons to support quarterback Aaron Rodgers, and Pitts could provide a significant upgrade at the tight end position.
Indianapolis Colts: The Colts have a young, promising quarterback in Anthony Richardson, and they could use a reliable tight end to complement their receiving corps. A move to Indianapolis would reunite Pitts with another former Florida Gator, potentially sparking a connection that could benefit both players.
Philadelphia Eagles: The Eagles are always looking for ways to improve their roster, and they could view Pitts as an upgrade over their current tight end, Dallas Goedert. A trade to Philadelphia would give Pitts the opportunity to play in a high-powered offense with a proven quarterback in Jalen Hurts.
Fantasy Football Impact of a Trade
A trade could have a significant impact on Pitts’ fantasy football value. A change of scenery could provide him with a fresh start and a better opportunity to showcase his talent.
Increased Target Share: In Atlanta, Pitts has had to compete for targets with Drake London and Bijan Robinson. On a new team, he could become the primary receiving option, leading to a significant increase in his target share.
Improved Quarterback Play: Inconsistent quarterback play has been a major factor in Pitts’ struggles. A trade to a team with a more established quarterback could lead to improved production.
Better Offensive Scheme: The Falcons’ offensive scheme has been criticized for not utilizing Pitts’ talents effectively. A trade to a team with a more creative offensive coordinator could unlock his full potential.
2025 NFL Draft Tight End Class
It is important to note the strength of the upcoming 2025 NFL Draft class at the tight end position. Penn State’s Tyler Warren and Michigan’s Colston Loveland are considered to be among the top prospects. LSU’s Mason Taylor, son of Hall of Fame edge rusher Jason Taylor, is another name to watch. If the Falcons feel they can find a suitable replacement in the draft, they may be more willing to trade Pitts.
Fantasy Football Outlook for Pitts in 2025
As of April 2025, it’s difficult to predict where Pitts will be playing next season. However, regardless of his team, his fantasy football outlook remains uncertain.
If Pitts stays in Atlanta: His fantasy value will likely remain in the TE2 range. He’ll need to show significant improvement in his connection with quarterback Michael Penix Jr. to warrant a higher draft pick.
If Pitts is traded: His fantasy value will depend on his destination. A trade to a team with a strong quarterback and a creative offensive scheme could elevate him into the TE1 conversation. However, a trade to a team with a crowded receiving corps or a questionable quarterback situation could further diminish his value.
Conclusion
Kyle Pitts is a talented player who has yet to live up to his potential in the NFL. A trade could be the best thing for his career, providing him with a fresh start and a better opportunity to showcase his skills. Fantasy football managers should monitor Pitts’ situation closely this offseason, as a trade could significantly impact his value in 2025.