Allen vs. Jackson: Ranking the NFL’s Top Quarterbacks After Super Bowl

Allen vs. Jackson: Ranking the NFL’s Top Quarterbacks After Super Bowl LIX

The confetti has settled after Super Bowl LIX, the echoes of roaring crowds have faded, and the NFL world is already dissecting the past season and projecting forward. One debate, as fierce as any rivalry on the field, continues to rage: Who reigns supreme among the league’s quarterbacks? While Patrick Mahomes remains in the conversation, the 2024 season saw Josh Allen of the Buffalo Bills and Lamar Jackson of the Baltimore Ravens solidify their places among the elite. But who stands taller after the dust has settled?

The Case for Josh Allen: MVP Caliber

Josh Allen’s 2024 season was nothing short of spectacular, earning him his first MVP award. He led the Buffalo Bills to another AFC East title, showcasing his incredible arm strength, mobility, and sheer will to win. Allen’s ability to make plays out of nothing, extending drives with his legs and delivering pinpoint throws under pressure, makes him a nightmare for opposing defenses.

Key Stats and Strengths:

  • Passing Yards: 3,731
  • Touchdowns: 28
  • MVP Award: Allen’s MVP win underscores his impact on the Bills’ success.
  • Dual-Threat Ability: Allen’s rushing ability complements his passing game, making him a dynamic threat. In the 2024-2025 season, he rushed for 524 yards and 15 touchdowns.
  • Leadership: Allen’s leadership on and off the field is undeniable, inspiring his teammates and galvanizing the Buffalo fanbase.

Despite losing key receivers from the previous year, Allen elevated the Bills’ offense, showcasing his adaptability and ability to make those around him better. His performance in the AFC Championship game, while ultimately a loss to the Kansas City Chiefs, further cemented his status as a top-tier quarterback.

The Case for Lamar Jackson: A Dual-Threat Dynamo

Lamar Jackson’s 2024 season was equally impressive, showcasing his unique blend of athleticism and passing prowess. He led the Baltimore Ravens to the AFC North title, orchestrating a high-powered offense that consistently put up points. Jackson’s ability to make defenders miss in the open field, coupled with his improved accuracy as a passer, makes him one of the most dangerous quarterbacks in the league.

Key Stats and Strengths:

  • Passing Yards: 4,172
  • Touchdowns: 41
  • Rushing Yards: 915
  • Efficiency: Jackson’s passer rating of 119.6 is a testament to his efficiency and decision-making.
  • Playmaking Ability: Jackson’s ability to extend plays with his legs and create opportunities for his receivers is unmatched.

Jackson’s performance earned him a spot in the Pro Bowl, further solidifying his status as one of the league’s best. While the Ravens fell short of their Super Bowl aspirations, Jackson’s individual brilliance was undeniable.

Head-to-Head Comparison: A Tale of Two Styles

When comparing Allen and Jackson, it’s essential to consider their contrasting styles. Allen is a gunslinger with a rocket arm, unafraid to take risks and make throws into tight windows. Jackson is a more calculated playmaker, relying on his athleticism and accuracy to dissect defenses.

Key Considerations:

  • Passing Prowess: Jackson’s passing yards and touchdowns numbers edge out Allen’s, suggesting a slight advantage in the passing game.
  • Rushing Impact: Both quarterbacks are dynamic runners, but Allen’s rushing touchdowns demonstrate his nose for the end zone.
  • Team Success: Both quarterbacks led their teams to division titles, but ultimately fell short in the playoffs.

The Verdict: A Matter of Preference

Ultimately, ranking Allen and Jackson comes down to a matter of preference. Both quarterbacks possess unique skills and have proven themselves to be among the league’s elite.

Some analysts favor Jackson’s efficiency and playmaking ability, while others value Allen’s arm strength and leadership. According to a February 2025 NFL Spin Zone article, Lamar Jackson ranked #1 and Josh Allen ranked #3 in final quarterback rankings after Super Bowl LIX.

The Next Chapter: 2025 and Beyond

As the NFL landscape continues to evolve, the rivalry between Allen and Jackson promises to be a defining storyline for years to come. Both quarterbacks are entering their prime, surrounded by talented teammates and driven to achieve Super Bowl glory.

Whether you’re a fan of Allen’s gunslinging style or Jackson’s electrifying playmaking, one thing is certain: the future of the NFL is in good hands with these two quarterbacks leading the charge.