Passing Grades: Evaluating the Performance of 2025 NFL Rookie Quarterbacks

The 2025 NFL season is upon us, and all eyes are on the incoming class of rookie quarterbacks. Unlike the star-studded classes of recent years, this year’s group presents a fascinating mix of potential franchise cornerstones and intriguing developmental projects. Will any of them replicate the immediate impact of C.J. Stroud in 2023 or Jayden Daniels in 2024? Or will they face the typical growing pains that often plague first-year signal-callers? Let’s dive into the passing grades for some of the most anticipated rookies.

Cam Ward: Tennessee Titans

Cam Ward, selected first overall, lands in Tennessee with the weight of expectation on his shoulders. The Titans have invested heavily in their offensive line, and Ward will have Calvin Ridley, who had over 1,000 receiving yards in 2024, as a reliable target.

Strengths: Ward is an experienced, dynamic player with the arm talent and athleticism to become a top-tier NFL quarterback. He displays exceptional accuracy and can make throws from multiple arm angles, fitting the ball into tight coverage. His ability to create when plays break down is a major asset.

Weaknesses: Ward needs a strong supporting cast to thrive. While the Titans have made efforts to improve the offense, it remains to be seen if it will be enough to support Ward’s development.

Potential Grade: B+

Jaxson Dart: New York Giants

Jaxson Dart joins the New York Giants, where he’ll have the opportunity to learn behind veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston. This developmental stability could be crucial for his long-term success.

Strengths: Dart possesses a big arm and plenty of toughness. He averaged 329 passing yards per game in his senior year at Ole Miss, showcasing his potential as a high-volume passer.

Weaknesses: Dart needs time to develop and adjust to a pro-style system. His raw traits require refinement before he can consistently perform at the NFL level.

Potential Grade: C+

Tyler Shough: New Orleans Saints

Tyler Shough finds himself in a favorable position with the New Orleans Saints, where he could compete for the starting job early in the season. The Saints’ quarterback situation is uncertain, giving Shough a real opportunity to prove himself.

Strengths: Shough has above-average arm talent and has demonstrated a flair for acrobatic plays. He also displays anticipation skills and a knack for keeping the ball out of harm’s way.

Weaknesses: Shough’s extensive injury history and older age (26) raise concerns about his long-term upside. He also lacks experience calling plays in a huddle.

Potential Grade: B-

Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders: Cleveland Browns

The Cleveland Browns present a unique situation with both Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders entering the mix. They will compete with Kenny Pickett and Joe Flacco for playing time, creating an intriguing quarterback battle.

Dillon Gabriel

Strengths: Gabriel is a smart processor and rhythm thrower. He is known for his anticipatory throws.

Weaknesses: Gabriel’s arm talent is below average, and his size is a concern.

Shedeur Sanders

Strengths: Sanders possesses great touch and precision in the short and intermediate game.

Weaknesses: Sanders has major issues with pocket mechanics.

Potential Grade (Gabriel): C

Potential Grade (Sanders): C+

Jalen Milroe: Seattle Seahawks

Jalen Milroe lands with the Seattle Seahawks, where he’ll likely begin his career as a backup. However, his unique athleticism could earn him a role in specialized packages.

Strengths: Milroe is the most physically gifted quarterback in this class, boasting elite athleticism and a powerful arm.

Weaknesses: Milroe needs significant development, particularly with his footwork and accuracy. He struggles with consistency and decision-making.

Potential Grade: C-

Will Howard: Pittsburgh Steelers

Will Howard joins the Pittsburgh Steelers, where he’ll have the opportunity to learn from a stable coaching staff.

Strengths: Howard is a polished, high-floor player with good size and toughness. He showed good improvement over the last three seasons.

Weaknesses: Howard is more of a game manager than a playmaker. He doesn’t possess special arm talent.

Potential Grade: C

Other Notable Rookies

Riley Leonard (Indianapolis Colts): Leonard has limitations as a downfield passer, but he may have landed in the best situation for his development.
Kyle McCord (Philadelphia Eagles): McCord is a fairly athletic quarterback who can make plays outside of the pocket.
Quinn Ewers (Miami Dolphins): Ewers has good size and passing talent, but durability and mobility concerns are impediments he will need to overcome.

Factors Influencing Rookie Performance

Several factors will play a crucial role in determining the success of these rookie quarterbacks:

Coaching: A quarterback-friendly head coach and offensive coordinator can make a significant difference in a rookie’s development. Brian Callahan in Tennessee, Kellen Moore in New Orleans, and Brian Daboll in New York are examples of coaches who could positively impact their young quarterbacks.
Supporting Cast: A strong offensive line, reliable receivers, and a consistent running game are essential for any quarterback to succeed, especially a rookie.
Opportunity: The path to playing time is crucial. Rookies like Cam Ward and Tyler Shough, who have a clear shot at starting early, have a greater chance to make an immediate impact.
System Fit: Landing in a system that aligns with a quarterback’s strengths is vital. For example, Riley Leonard’s athleticism and RPO skills could be a great fit in Shane Steichen’s offense in Indianapolis.

Final Thoughts

The 2025 NFL season promises to be an exciting one for rookie quarterbacks. While this class may not have the same level of hype as previous years, it is filled with intriguing prospects who could develop into valuable players. Keep an eye on these young signal-callers as they navigate the challenges of the NFL and strive to earn passing grades.