Colts’ Tyler Warren: The Undrafted Rookie TE Poised for Pro Bowl Consideration?
The Indianapolis Colts may have unearthed a gem in undrafted rookie tight end Tyler Warren. While the term “undrafted” often carries a stigma, Warren’s performance in training camp and the preseason is quickly turning heads and sparking conversations about his potential impact on the Colts’ offense – and perhaps even a Pro Bowl nod down the line.
From Penn State Standout to Colts Hopeful
Tyler Warren’s journey to the NFL wasn’t paved with the typical accolades and draft hype. Despite a productive career at Penn State, where he showcased versatility as both a receiver and blocker, Warren went unselected in the 2025 NFL Draft. However, Chris Ballard and the Colts’ scouting department saw something special in the 6’6″, 261-pound tight end, and quickly signed him as a free agent.
Warren’s final season with the Nittany Lions was nothing short of spectacular. He hauled in 104 receptions for 1,233 receiving yards and eight touchdowns, earning the prestigious John Mackey Award, given to the nation’s top tight end. He even added 218 rushing yards and four touchdowns on the ground, demonstrating his unique ability to contribute in multiple facets of the game. In fact, Warren became the first Big Ten tight end since 1956 to rush for four scores in a single season.
Training Camp Buzz and Preseason Promise
Since arriving in Indianapolis, Tyler Warren has consistently impressed coaches and teammates alike. His work ethic, attention to detail, and natural talent have been on full display during training camp. Veteran left guard Quenton Nelson, a seven-time Pro Bowler, praised Warren’s dedication, noting that the rookie is “always trying to get better each day.”
Head coach Shane Steichen has also been effusive in his praise of Warren, highlighting his “great hands, natural route running, and great feel for the game.” Steichen believes Warren can “find the dead spots in zone coverage” and “win versus man with his big body.”
Warren’s impressive training camp performance translated to the preseason opener against the Baltimore Ravens. On an out-breaking route towards the sideline, Warren flattened his route off and caught a pass from quarterback Daniel Jones, shielding the pass from a defensive back who could’ve knocked it away had Warren rounded his route and drifted upfield.
A Versatile Weapon for the Colts’ Offense
Tyler Warren’s versatility is perhaps his greatest asset. He possesses the size and strength to be an effective in-line blocker, but also the athleticism and receiving skills to line up as a flex tight end or even in the slot. This versatility gives offensive coordinator Jim Bob Cooter the flexibility to create mismatches and exploit defensive weaknesses.
With Anthony Richardson’s strong arm and Tyler Warren’s reliable hands, the Colts’ passing game could reach new heights in 2025. Warren’s ability to win contested catches and make plays in the red zone will be invaluable for Richardson, providing him with a trusted target in crucial situations.
The Path to a Pro Bowl?
While it’s still early, the buzz surrounding Tyler Warren is undeniable. If he can continue to develop his skills, refine his technique, and build chemistry with Anthony Richardson, there’s no reason why he can’t become a Pro Bowl-caliber player.
Of course, the path to a Pro Bowl is never easy, especially for an undrafted rookie. Warren will face stiff competition from established tight ends around the league. He’ll need to prove that his training camp and preseason success can translate to regular-season production.
However, Tyler Warren has the talent, work ethic, and opportunity to defy the odds. He’s already impressed his coaches and teammates, and he’s quickly gaining the attention of NFL fans. If he can continue on this trajectory, a Pro Bowl appearance may not be as far-fetched as it seems.
The Colts’ tight end depth chart currently lists Warren as TE1, followed by Drew Ogletree, Mo Alie-Cox, and Will Mallory. While Alie-Cox and Ogletree are known for their blocking abilities, Warren’s potential as a pass-catcher gives him a significant advantage in terms of playing time and opportunities.
Conclusion
Tyler Warren’s emergence as a potential Pro Bowl contender is a testament to his hard work, dedication, and natural talent. He’s quickly becoming a fan favorite in Indianapolis, and his impact on the Colts’ offense could be significant in 2025 and beyond. Keep an eye on #84 – he might just be the next big thing at the tight end position.