Super Bowl V: Baltimore’s Narrow Victory at the Orange Bowl – 16-13 Win over Dallas
Super Bowl V, held on January 17, 1971, at Miami’s Orange Bowl, remains one of the most talked-about games in NFL history. The Baltimore Colts and the Dallas Cowboys battled fiercely, resulting in a narrow 16-13 victory for the Colts, sealed by a last-second field goal. However, the game is equally remembered for its numerous errors and unusual circumstances, earning it the moniker “The Blunder Bowl.”
A Game of Firsts and Lasts
Super Bowl V marked several significant milestones. It was the first Super Bowl played after the AFL-NFL merger, integrating the two leagues into a unified NFL structure. The Colts, previously representing the NFL in Super Bowl III, now represented the AFC, while the Cowboys represented the NFC. The game was also the first Super Bowl played on artificial turf, specifically first-generation Poly-Turf.
Adding to the game’s unique legacy, Dallas Cowboys linebacker Chuck Howley became the only player from a losing team to be named Super Bowl MVP. His two interceptions and a fumble recovery were overshadowed by Baltimore’s eventual win, making his award a bittersweet honor.
The “Blunder Bowl”
The game lived up to its unflattering nickname with a combined Super Bowl record of 11 turnovers. The Colts fumbled seven times, the most ever committed by a Super Bowl-winning team. Dallas contributed with four turnovers and a Super Bowl record of 10 penalties for 133 yards. The sloppy play, missed opportunities, and officiating miscues contributed to the game’s chaotic nature.
Early in the game, Cowboys linebacker Chuck Howley intercepted a pass from Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas, setting the tone for a turnover-filled contest. The Cowboys capitalized, with Mike Clark kicking a 14-yard field goal to put Dallas on the board. Clark added another field goal in the second quarter, extending Dallas’s lead.
Unitas’s Injury and Morrall’s Entry
Adding to the Colts’ woes, quarterback Johnny Unitas sustained a rib injury in the second quarter, forcing him to leave the game. Veteran Earl Morrall, stepped in to lead the offense. Despite Unitas’s injury, he managed to connect with John Mackey for a 75-yard touchdown pass, though the extra point was blocked. Duane Thomas then caught a 7-yard touchdown pass from Craig Morton, giving Dallas a 13-6 lead at halftime.
The third quarter remained scoreless, with both teams struggling to maintain possession. However, the Colts mounted a comeback in the fourth quarter. Tom Nowatzke scored on a 2-yard touchdown run, and Jim O’Brien converted the extra point, tying the game at 13-13.
O’Brien’s Game-Winning Kick
With seconds remaining, the Colts drove into field goal range. Rookie kicker Jim O’Brien stepped up and booted a 32-yard field goal with just five seconds left on the clock, securing a 16-13 victory for Baltimore. O’Brien’s kick marked the then-record for least time in the lead for a Super Bowl champion.
Howley’s Historic MVP Performance
Despite the loss, Chuck Howley’s performance stood out. He recorded two interceptions and recovered a fumble, earning him the Super Bowl MVP award. Howley remains the only player from a losing team to receive the honor.
Bubba Smith’s Discontent
Despite the Super Bowl victory, Colts defensive end Bubba Smith refused to wear his Super Bowl V ring, expressing his dissatisfaction with the “sloppy” play. His sentiment reflected the mixed feelings surrounding the game, where victory was achieved amidst numerous mistakes.
Game Statistics and Top Performers
Earl Morrall led the Colts in passing with 147 yards, while Unitas contributed 88 yards and a touchdown before his injury. John Mackey was the game’s top receiver with 80 yards and a touchdown. Tom Nowatzke led the Colts in rushing with 33 yards and a touchdown.
For the Cowboys, Walt Garrison led in rushing, and Duane Thomas scored a touchdown. However, quarterback Craig Morton struggled, throwing three interceptions.
A Memorable Super Bowl
Super Bowl V remains a memorable game for its numerous errors, unusual MVP selection, and dramatic finish. While it may not be remembered for its quality of play, it undoubtedly holds a unique place in Super Bowl history. The Baltimore Colts’ narrow victory over the Dallas Cowboys serves as a testament to the unpredictable nature of football and the ability of a team to overcome adversity, even in the face of numerous mistakes.