Rodgers to Pittsburgh? The Steelers’ QB Conundrum in 2025
The Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback situation has been a revolving door since Ben Roethlisberger’s retirement after the 2021 season. Despite attempts to find a long-term solution, the Steelers find themselves yet again searching for stability under center as they approach the 2025 season. The latest chapter in this saga involves the potential arrival of veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers, but is “Rodgers to Pittsburgh” a realistic possibility, and what does it mean for the Steelers’ future?
The Aaron Rodgers Saga: A Lingering Question Mark
The Steelers have reportedly expressed interest in acquiring Aaron Rodgers, a four-time NFL MVP, to bring leadership and experience to the team. The team even met with Rodgers in Pittsburgh a few weeks ago. However, Rodgers’ decision remains uncertain, with retirement being a possible consideration.
Adding to the intrigue, NFL Network’s Mike Garafolo reported that Rodgers and newly acquired Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf had a throwing session in Los Angeles. This fuels speculation that Rodgers is seriously considering joining the Steelers, especially with the prospect of playing alongside Metcalf and George Pickens.
However, Rodgers’ situation is complicated. After suffering an Achilles injury in 2023, Rodgers has dealt with various injuries. He has even resisted getting medical scans done, not wanting to reveal the severity of his injuries out of fear of having to come off the field.
Adding another layer of uncertainty, Rodgers is also dealing with personal responsibilities that are taking precedence over making a commitment to a new NFL team. He is helping friends rebuild their lives after they lost family heirlooms and other irreplaceable items.
The Steelers’ Options Beyond Rodgers
With Rodgers’ future unclear, the Steelers are exploring other quarterback options. General Manager Omar Khan stated that “all options are on the table,” including free agency, trades, and the draft. Coach Mike Tomlin has also said that Rodgers’ situation does not impact how the Steelers approach the draft.
Here are some potential alternatives the Steelers might consider:
- Kirk Cousins: With the Atlanta Falcons choosing to start rookie quarterback Michael Penix Jr., Cousins may be open to joining another team where he can continue as a starter. The Steelers could offer him that chance. However, Cousins’ contract is massive, and the Falcons are reportedly seeking a team willing to take on a substantial portion of his salary.
- Drafting a Quarterback: The Steelers could select a quarterback in the 2025 NFL Draft. Some potential targets include Jaxson Dart from Ole Miss and Jalen Milroe from Alabama.
- Joe Milton III: The New England Patriots are exploring trade options for the young quarterback. A trade to acquire Milton shouldn’t be expensive, and the Steelers have plenty of draft capital to pull something like this off.
What Does This Mean for the Steelers’ QB Future?
The Steelers’ pursuit of Aaron Rodgers, or any other veteran quarterback, suggests a desire to compete immediately. The team has a talented roster, including Metcalf, Pickens, and a promising offensive line. Adding a proven quarterback could elevate them into Super Bowl contention.
However, relying solely on a short-term solution like Rodgers or Cousins could delay the development of a long-term franchise quarterback. The Steelers need to balance their desire to win now with the need to secure their quarterback position for the future.
General Manager Omar Khan admits that the revolving door at quarterback “is not ideal.” “At some point, we have to find the long-term solution. I’ll say that might happen this year. It could happen next year, but in the meantime, we’re going to keep doing whatever we can to win a championship this year.”
The Clock is Ticking
The Steelers have been waiting on Aaron Rodgers to make a decision regarding his future for over a month, and at some point, general manager Omar Khan must move on and think about external options. The 2025 NFL Draft is fast approaching, and the Steelers need to decide how to address their quarterback situation.
The Steelers have always taken at least four quarterbacks to training camp each season. With Mason Rudolph and Skylar Thompson currently the only quarterbacks on the team’s roster, the Steelers will need to add at least two more quarterbacks before training camp.
The Steelers’ quarterback situation remains fluid. Whether they land Rodgers, trade for Cousins, draft a quarterback, or stick with Rudolph, the Steelers’ decision will have a significant impact on their fortunes in 2025 and beyond.